The short answer
No. On November 9, 2026, EPA asked for public comment on its preferred way to address perchlorate in groundwater at the Shieldalloy site in New Jersey. The state agreed with that choice. EPA’s plan says the agency can still change it after considering comments. The document to look for is a Record of Decision for Operable Unit 3, the part of the site investigation that covers perchlorate.
Dossier Editorial prepared this educational case study with AI assistance using public records. No private matter, platform investigation, independent field sampling or human legal review was involved. The PDF uses the same findings and sources.
What can a property reviewer put in the file today?
Record “EPA prefers Alternative 2; New Jersey concurs; final selection not verified.” Alternative 2 would rely on natural processes to lower perchlorate concentrations. It also calls for investigation before design, monitoring to see whether the approach works, controls on groundwater use, and treatment at the point of entry if needed. The state’s November 6 letter supports those elements. On November 9, EPA invited comments on all the options.[S1][S6][S2]
A reviewer might already have a document titled Record of Decision for Shieldalloy groundwater. The September 1996 decision is real, but its cover says OU 01. It addressed metals and volatile organic compounds. It cannot answer whether EPA selected a perchlorate remedy in 2026. Keep the contaminant and unit number beside the site name wherever the conclusion will be reused.[S3][S1][S4]
Match the site, the water and the unit
Use EPA site ID NJD002365930. This is the former Shieldalloy Metallurgical Corporation facility in Newfield Borough, with part of the site in Vineland, New Jersey. The groundwater under investigation is distinct from water delivered to a building. A monitoring well measures the aquifer at a particular location and depth; a utility connection describes how a property receives water.[S5][S1]
EPA split the work into three operable units. OU1 covers groundwater contaminants other than perchlorate. OU2 covers non-perchlorate contamination in soil, sediment and surface water. OU3 investigated perchlorate across several media; EPA’s proposed action concerns groundwater. Plumes can overlap on a map without making the earlier decision applicable to the later contaminant.[S1][S4]
Read the records in decision order
| Date | What the record says | What it establishes |
|---|---|---|
| Sept 24, 1996 | NJDEP selected a groundwater remedy for OU1 with EPA concurrence. | An earlier final decision with a different scope.[S3][S4] |
| 2014 and 2015 | EPA recorded the OU2 decision on Sept 25, 2014 and the OU1 amendment on Sept 30, 2015. | Neither entry selects an OU3 remedy.[S4][S1] |
| October 2026 | Geosyntec’s study for Shieldalloy compared four OU3 options. | An engineering comparison prepared for the company.[S7] |
| Nov 6, 2026 | NJDEP signed a letter concurring with Alternative 2. | State support for the proposal.[S6] |
| Nov 9, 2026 | EPA opened comments on its plan and scheduled a Nov 19 meeting. | A public participation step. The meeting was still ahead at this review.[S1][S2] |
Two numbers to keep out of the wrong column
Cost: $1,856,500 is the estimated present value of Alternative 2 over 30 years. The feasibility study used a 7% discount rate and lists $641,000 in capital costs. Its comparison table expressly excludes the pre-design investigation, even though the proposed remedy includes that work. The table compares options. It does not give an all-in contract price, establish who owes that amount, or document a payment.[S7][S1]
Water quality: EPA’s proposed groundwater goal is 5 micrograms of perchlorate per liter. Figure 4 labels monitoring well SC-1D at 24 micrograms per liter on October 9, 2024. Those are different kinds of numbers: a proposed goal and a historical measurement. The plan estimates 20 to 30 years to reach its objectives. Neither figure tells a buyer what came out of a particular tap on November 10, 2026.[S1]
The alternative labeled “No Action” does not include monitoring or well controls. Alternative 2 does. EPA also compared pumping and treating groundwater and treating it in place. New Jersey’s agreement is documented, but community acceptance and EPA’s final selection are separate questions. The schedule showed an estimated decision window, not an issued OU3 decision.[S1][S4][S6][S7]
Which claim are you being asked to verify?
01Is the record about this unit and contaminant?
If establishedMatch the site ID, OU3 and perchlorate. Then read the document title and decision language.
If unresolvedFile an OU1 or OU2 decision under its own unit. A matching address is insufficient.
02Has EPA made its final selection?
If establishedRead the signed OU3 Record of Decision, its selected alternative and response to comments. Check for later amendments.
If unresolvedRecord the preference, state concurrence and public comment stage separately. A folder labeled “ROD” can contain documents gathered before the decision.
03Has spending or cleanup performance been verified?
If establishedFor spending, reconcile authorized costs with dated payment records. For performance, compare quality-checked samples against the applicable goal at matched wells and depths.
If unresolvedRetain the estimate, forecast or old measurement with its date. Leave actual payments and current water quality open.
Reproduce this review in Dossier
- Create a public-source case for EPA site NJD002365930. Add three questions: What did EPA propose for OU3? Has it selected a remedy? What shows that the groundwater goal has been met?
- Attach the proposal, NJDEP letter, original OU1 decision and engineering study as distinct sources. Save the site schedule and news notice with retrieval dates. Label Geosyntec as the study author and Shieldalloy as its client; EPA hosts the copy.
- Create separate timeline entries for the state letter and EPA’s announcement. In the cost finding, attach study section 5.5.7 and retain the pre-design exclusion. In the water finding, attach Figure 4 and record the well, units and sample date.
- Export the findings with a separate status for each question. A second reader should be able to reproduce the preferred alternative, identify why the OU1 decision was set aside, and locate the evidence still needed for an OU3 outcome.
- [S1][S3][S5][S6][S7]
What evidence would change the conclusion?
For final selection, look for EPA’s signed OU3 Record of Decision and its response to public comments. For implementation, obtain the design and evidence that the specified controls took effect. For performance, seek dated monitoring results under that design. A property-specific water question also needs a verified supply source and relevant sampling; this case study does not assess an individual property.[S1][S4]
One small discrepancy matters to anyone following the public process: EPA’s news release gives December 9 as the mail postmark date. The proposed plan gives December 11, and both list December 11 as the end of the comment period. Preserve both statements and check EPA’s current instructions before relying on a mailing date. This review found no basis to treat the two dates as interchangeable.[S1][S2]
Questions readers ask
Does the state’s signed letter make Alternative 2 final?
No. The letter agrees with the proposed alternative. EPA’s plan reserves the final choice until after it considers public comments.[S6][S1]
Is monitored natural attenuation the same as doing nothing?
No. The no-action option provides no monitoring. The preferred option calls for checking how concentrations change, restricting groundwater use and adding point-of-entry treatment if needed.[S1][S7]
Source register
Original records and agency pages. Each reference identifies its role and limits.
S1Shieldalloy OU3 proposed plan
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · Proposed remedy · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: Nov 9, 2026, pp. 1–3, 8–9, 13–15, 20–21 and Figure 4
Distinguishes alternatives, measured concentrations, cost assumptions and the decision still to come.
S2EPA announces public comment on the Shieldalloy plan
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · Agency notice · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: Nov 9, 2026, proposal, meeting and comment instructions
Its December 9 mail instruction differs from the plan’s December 11 postmark date.
S31996 groundwater Record of Decision, OU 01
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection · State remedy selection, EPA concurrence · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: PDF cover and Declaration for the Record of Decision, pp. 5–6
Identifies the first groundwater unit and treatment of metals and volatile organic compounds.
S4Shieldalloy cleanup schedule by operable unit
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · Site milestone register · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: Site milestones and OU 01, 02 and 03 decision rows
Actual entries and planning estimates have different status. This register can change.
S5Shieldalloy site documents and administrative records
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · Official site and record index · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: Administrative Records and Site Data, EPA ID NJD002365930
The OU3 collection title identifies a file, not the issuance of a final remedy.
S6NJDEP’s concurrence with the OU3 proposal
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection · Signed state letter · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: Nov 6, 2026, p. 1, subject and preferred remedy components
State concurrence applies to the proposed alternative and its conditional treatment provisions.
S7Final OU3 focused feasibility study
Geosyntec Consultants, Inc. · Engineering study prepared for Shieldalloy · Checked November 10, 2026
Anchor: October 2026 cover; sections 5.2.7 and 5.5.7, PDF pp. 37 and 57
Specifies the discount rate and the pre-design cost exclusion. Final describes the study, not a decision by EPA.